Conservation and management of agricultural land by traditional methods in Machida City, Tokyo, Japan
DATE OF SUBMISSION :
Japan (Machida City, Tokyo)
Machida City is located approximately 30 kilometers from central Tokyo, Japan. Rapid residential development, beginning in the 1970s, saw the population of Machida City increase 6.6-fold between 1958 and 2005. As a result of the increased use of cheap fossil fuels and chemical fertilizers, the advantage of being able to collect fuels and compost from the nearby forests in “ yato” (valley-shaped landforms formed by erosion of hills) was lost, despite the recycle-oriented utilization of natural resources practiced there in the past. Lack of adequate management resulted in uncontrolled ecological succession and deterioration in the quality of the remaining natural environment even after 37,000 square meters of the area had been designated as a publicly owned conservation area. Consequently, the animals and plants characteristic of yato have decreased significantly. In response, local residents organized an association called “Machida Rekikan Kanri Kumiai” and proposed that local farmers who are familiar with traditional agricultural practices should be in charge of the vegetation management in publicly owned “ yato” conservation areas. The main activities of the association include vegetation management, infrastructure-related work, restoration of “ yato”, and wildlife interventions. This project is a rare example of local management of publicly owned land and has multi-dimensional significance, such as the utilization of traditional knowledge and the improvement of biodiversity through the reintroduction of human interventions.
human intervention, yato, traditional agriculture
Ms. Takako Matsui She has been working at PREC Institute Inc. since 1982, and is currently the manager of environmental coexistence division. Until today, she has been engaged in work such as survey and planning related to conservation and utilization of natural environment, supporting community involvement and creation of social consensus in rural development, and developing technical guidelines for environment impact assessments. Currently, she takes charge of work on the Satoyama Initiative, survey and planning related to natural parks, and others. Mr. Taito Kawashima He has been working at PREC Institute Inc. since 1997, and is currently the vice manager of environmental coexistence division. Until today, he has been engaged in work such as survey and planning related to conservation and utilization of natural environment, survey on conservation of agricultural land and promotion of agriculture, planning related to measures against global warming. Currently, he works on the Satoyama Initiative, survey work related to agriculture and biodiversity, and others. Mr. Takehiro Kasahara He has been working at PREC Institute Inc. since 2007, and is a researcher of environmental coexistence division. Until today, he has been engaged in work such as survey and planning related to conservation and utilization of natural environment and environment impact assessments. Currently, he works on the Satoyama Initiative, survey and planning work related to natural parks, and others.
For more details, please refer to the link below.
The Tokyo Metropolitan Government has designated approximately 37,000 square metersof the Zushi-Onoji region of Machida City where traditional land uses and agriculture of the yato area are still present as the “Zushi-Onoji Historical and Environmental Conservation Area” under a ordinance of Tokyo.Among these conservation areas, agricultural land owned by Tokyo is conserved and managed by the Machida Rekikan Kanri Kumiai (History and Environment Management Association), the local farmers’ association, using traditional methods.
1. Regional Profile
Machida City, Tokyo, Japan is located approximately 30 kilometres from central Tokyo. Machida City had been an agricultural area until the mid-twentieth century; rapid residential development started in the 1970s and today it has become a bedroom town in Tokyo. The population of Machida City grew from 61,105 people in 1958 to 405,534 people in 2005, a 6.6-fold increase due to the rapid residential development in the 1970s,.
The major part of the administrative territory of Machida City is the hill area, which ranges from 27 to 363 metres in altitude. The climate of the region is warm and humid; the annual average temperature is about 14 degrees Celsius and the annual precipitation is about 1,600 millimetres.
In the northern part of Machida City, yato (valley-shaped landforms formed by the erosion of the hill) and traditional land uses such as secondary forests, rice paddies and other types of natural environments still remain. The plants and animals that have become rare in urban and suburban areas today can still be seen in this area. The animals and plants characteristic of the yato area include raptors, the umbrella species of the region (eg. northern goshawk), insects inhabiting forests, and plants that grow in rice paddies and canals.
The natural environment has been decreasing in surface due to the development of the region in the recent years. In addition, lack of adequate management has resulted in uncontrolled ecological succession and deterioration in the quality of the remaining natural environment. As a result, the animals and plants that typically used to be seen in the yato area have decreased significantly to the extent that many species are now listed in the Red Lists of threatened species at the national level (Threatened Wildlife of Japan: Red Data Book) or Tokyo level (Important Wildlife for protection in Tokyo).
2. The Use and Management of Natural Resources in the Region
2.1 The Use and Management of Natural Resources in the Past and Present
Traditional land uses that suit the complex landforms have generally been carried out in the northern part of Machida City. Agricultural lands and human settlements are located on the narrow flatlands along rivers. Forests are distributed on hills that surround such areas. Particularly in the yato area, there are traditional land uses characterized by a mixture of rice paddies that use natural spring water taken from the river source, secondary forests on slopes, farmlands, and human settlements.
In agricultural lands of the yato area, rice, vegetables, and fruits are produced for human consumption as well as livestock husbandry. In forests, timber, charcoal, and compost used to be produced; however, the amount of their production has been reduced significantly in recent years.
2.2 The Problems Associated with the Use and Management of Natural Resources and its Impact on Biodiversity
Landforms and land use have changed as a result of the development of the hilly areas into residential areas since the 1960s in Machida City. Forests and agricultural lands, which are important habitats and nurturing grounds for wild animals, have been significantly reduced.
Moreover, due to the increased use of cheap fossil fuels and chemical fertilizers, the advantage of being able to collect fuels and compost from the nearby forests has been lost especially in the yato area, where the recycle-oriented utilization of natural resources was practiced in the past. Meanwhile, the difficulty of improving agricultural efficiency due to the narrow land and slopes, which is one of the disadvantages of the yato area, has become apparent. Therefore, the area is regarded as low-valued for land use, and development and abandoned management have been increasing.
2.3 Regional Plans and Other Measures toward Resolution of the Above Problems
One of the policies of the “Machida City Environmental Master Plan”, prepared in 2002, is to conserve and restore the natural, historical, and cultural environment. The City is working on the conservation and restoration of the secondary natural environment, as it is represented in the yato area, through a partnership with landowners, nonprofit organizations, volunteers, and other participants.
Meanwhile, the Tokyo Metropolitan Government has designated the area of Machida City where traditional land uses and agriculture of the yato area are still present as the “Zushi-Onoji Historical and Environmental Conservation Area” under a ordinance of Tokyo. In addition, a conservation plan concerning policies and regulations for the protection and restoration of nature to promote the conservation of the natural, historical, and cultural environment of the yato area has been prepared.
3. Overview of the Case Study
3.1 Background and history of activities
In light of the value of the natural, historical, and cultural environment of the case study area and as stated above, the Tokyo Metropolitan Government designated the relevant area as the “Zushi-Onoji Historical and Environmental Conservation Area” in 1978. This conservation area was designated with a principle to limited public entry to achieve conservation of natural environment thorough agricultural practices, and strict regulation on the use of the conservation area was implemented.
However, farmers who were affected by the national government’s policy to reduce the acreage of agricultural land lost their will to continue agricultural operations on privately owned land within the conservation area. They stopped farming practices and the remaining land deteriorated due to abandonment. Moreover, in publicly owned land within the conservation area, proper management was not implemented.
Troubled by the above-mentioned circumstances, local residents organized the Machida Rekikan Kanri Kumiai (History and Environment Management Association) (hereinafter referred to as “The Association”). They proposed that local farmers who are familiar with traditional agricultural practices should be in charge of the vegetation management of publicly owned yato areas within the conservation area.
Based on the proposal, the Tokyo Metropolitan Government commissioned the vegetation management to the Association.
3.2 Main Content of the effort
The mission of the Association is to “secure biological diversity”, to “conserve yato landscapes in good condition”, and to “implement management with a focus on the conservation of the aquatic environment and water control in the upstream area”.
Main activities of the association include vegetation management (eg. mowing and raking fallen leaves), infrastructure-related work (eg. installation of signs), restoration of yato (restoration of abandoned yato areas in order to create waterside environments that provide habitats to wildlife), wildlife interventions (eg. removal of crows in order to protect the breeding and nurturing grounds of the Northern Goshawk ( Accipiter gentilis).
Picture 2: Yato before (above) management and under management (below) *Photograph: Koichi Tagoku
Picture 2: Yato before (above) management and under management (below) *Photograph: Koichi Tagoku
4. The Use and Management of Natural Resources from the Perspectives of the Satoyama Initiative
4.1 Resource use within the carrying capacity and resilience of the environment
The land use that combines various features including irrigated rice fields in yato and forests on slopes was established as a suitable land use method for the natural environment involving the topography, soil, and climate in yato. The sustainable management and utilization of natural resources within the range of the environmental carrying capacity and resilience of the natural environment used to be practiced in the yato area in the past. Thanks to such practices, a healthy natural environment that had nurtured great biodiversity has been retained. Efforts in this area aim to pass on the land use of yato which is adapted to such natural environment to future generations.
The Association which is commissioned by the Tokyo Metropolitan Government to manage the area’s vegetation fully understands the ecosystems and ecosystem services of the area and manages the area under the three policies highlighted in table 1.
Table 1. Relationship between the management policy of the Association and the value of ecosystems and ecosystem services
|Management policy||Values of relevant ecosystems and ecosystem services|
|Secure biological diversity||• Biodiversity|
|Conserve yato landscape in good condition||• Cultural service (historical and cultural environment)|
|Implement management with focus on the conservation of aquatic environments and upstream water control||• Supply service (nurture water resources)• Adjustment service (flood control)|
The Tokyo Metropolitan Government and researchers are continuing biological surveys. They assess individual survey outcomes and examine the effectiveness of the efforts through comparative progress analysis of these outcomes. Table 2 describes an example of such impacts.
Table 2. An example of positive impacts of traditional methods on the conservation of biodiversity
|1986||• The “Investigation of the Flora and Fauna of the Zushi-Onoji History and Environment Conservation Area”, conducted by the Bureau of Environment, the Tokyo Metropolitan Government in 1986 before the start of the yato management work, identified 591 species (115 families) of native plants.|
|1996 to 2002||• Surveys conducted from 1996 to 2002 identified 680 species (128 families) of native plants. In comparison to the 1986 survey, 89 additional plant species were recorded.• Additional species included many rare species.• The number of plant species clearly increased since the start of the yato management work.|
Source: Report of Commissioned Survey on Precious Plant Species in the Zushi-Onoji History and Environment Conservation Area, Tama Environment Office, The Tokyo Metropolitan Government and Ryokusei Research Institute Inc. 2002.
4.2 Recognizing the value and importance of local traditions and cultures
The Tokyo Metropolitan Government conducted an “Investigation of Methods to Manage yato in the Conservation Area” in 1995. The study compared the biota between the yato where rice paddies were maintained and the abandoned yato. It also examined traditional methods practiced by local farmers to take care of yato. The investigation found that in abandoned yato, rice paddies had changed to dry land and the environmental features became homogeneous. On the other hand, yato in which irrigated rice farming was continued had small environmental segments such as farm roads, irrigational canals, reservoirs, and levees between rice fields, and the combination of these segments with the surrounding forests resulted in a mosaic of different land uses that were associated with high biodiversity.
The Association produced a manual on traditional skills that were studied in the above investigation and is implementing vegetation management work in accordance with the manual. The goals of the vegetation management work included the restoration of traditional environmental segments and traditional agricultural civil engineering skills were adopted in individual projects.
As a result of the reintroduction of such traditional knowledge into present-day vegetation management work, the abandoned yato has been successfully restored.
4.3 Natural resource management by various participating and cooperating entities
The stakeholders in this area include the Tokyo Metropolitan Government, the landowner, and the Association, the vegetation manager, as well as people from different sectors such as researchers (Liaison Committee for History and Environment Researchers) (table 3). The projects are conducted through role assignments and cooperation based on position and expertise.
Table 3. Stakeholders and role assignments of this project
|Zushi-Onoji Historical and Environmental Conservation Area (publicly owned land)||The Tokyo Metropolitan Government||Land owner; executor of conservation policies|
|Machida Rekikan-Kanri-Kumiai (non-governmental organization of local farmers)||Management work (commissioned by the Tokyo Metropolitan Government)|
|Liaison Committee for History and Environment Researchers (a network of experts who are involved in research on the conservation of the natural environment and the historical and cultural environment of the case study area)||Conduct biological monitoring and provide expert opinions.|
|Machida City, private companies, and volunteers||Provide human and financial resources.|
4.4 Contributions to local socio-economics
Farmers who are the members of the Association feel threatened by the deteriorating natural, historical, and cultural environment of yato, which they have nurtured for many generations. They are certain and proud that they have inherited traditional wisdom and are capable of restoring the environment. They are translating these feelings into actions, successfully producing positive results.
This project is a rare example of the management of publicly owned land by local residents. Only a few examples of similar cases are to be found in Japan. In addition, this project has multi-dimensional significance, such as the inheritance and utilization of traditional knowledge of the region and the improvement of biodiversity through the reintroduction of human interventions for management purposes. Therefore, this project is attracting attention from the stakeholders living in the suburban area near a large city who face similar problems, and several prizes have been awarded to this project.
The local farmers have become more proud of their own occupation, which contributes to the conservation of the natural environment as well as the historical and cultural heritage, and the bond within the community has become stronger.
About the study
This study was carried out by the members of PREC Institute Inc., Takako Matsui, Taito Kawashima, and Takehiro Kasahara, as a part of a contract work with the Ministry of the Environment, Japan. The study is based on hearing surveys on Mr Koichi Tagoku, the director of the Machida Rekikan Kanri Kumiai, and the natural environment division of the environment department of Tokyo, as well as field surveys and literature surveys.
We would like to give our special thanks to those parties who cooperated with us to carry out this study.