Investigation and screening of aboriginal plants as habitat creation plants for beneficial insects in tribes in Hualien

04.06.2023

SUBMITTING ORGANIZATION

Hualien District Agricultural Research and Extension Station COA., R.O.C. (Taiwan)

DATE OF SUBMISSION

24/05/2023

REGION

Asia

COUNTRY

Chinese Taipei

KEYWORDS

Organic cultivation, rice paddy, pomelo, agro-ecosystem, pest regulation, habitat creation

AUTHORS

Chia-Yi Wu1, Lily Lin1*, Zhong-Tai Li1, Shau-Ching Lin1, and Chih-Ying Yu2

1 Hualien District Agricultural Research and Extension Station COA., R.O.C.(Taiwan)

2 Hualien District Agricultural Research and Extension Station Lanyang Branch, COA., R.O.C.(Taiwan)

*Corresponded

Summary Sheet

The summary sheet for this case study is available here.

Abstracts

There are many aboriginal tribes in Hualien, Taiwan. Due to the special locations, they play the roles of connecting human farming activities and ecosystem protection. In our research, we try to figure out what kinds of beneficial insects, also called natural enemies, exist in tribal farming fields. And if we hope to keep the beneficial insects in fields, what kind of foods and environment shall be provided. In order to collect the background information in rice paddies and pomelo orchards, we did the investigation of insects’ species between different farming methods. In rice paddies, results showed that the population of total insects were higher in organic paddies than conventional ones, especially spiders (Tetragnathidae), Empididae and total parasitoids. Population of key pest planthoppers raised in earlier stage in conventional paddies than in organic ones. In pomelo orchards, the spider populations were obviously more stable in organic orchards. During small fruits stage, population of the key pest thrips was much higher in conventional orchards than in organic ones. In the lifespan assay of Dirhinus giffardii, we provided 10 kinds of aboriginal plants as the potential habitat for this parasitic natural enemy. The results showed that 7 of them, especially Indigofera spicata, Vitex trifolia and Anster indicus could extend the lifespan of D. giffardii.

Background introduction

Aboriginal tribes in Taiwan’s east coast are located between Central Mountains and Coast Mountains. Environment in tribes are clean and mostly isolated. The tribes play the important roles of connecting human activities and primitive natural environment, which symbolize the satoyama spirit. Agricultural fields in tribes are located near forests and source or head of river. Because of this unique positions, they possess diverse but fragile ecology. These years due to the climate changes, agricultural production face many external challenges, especially in the regulation and control of pests. More and more producers, including producers in tribes, rely on and raise the usage of chemical pesticides and herbicides. Due to the unique environment as we mentioned, threatens to ecology in tribes will be more severe than in normal countryside. Recognized this difficult situation, we notice and consider the important connection between aboriginal farming and agro-ecosystem. By the combination of aboriginal plants and ecofriendly farming, we hope to strength the ecosystem in tribes. Our ultimate objective is the solution to promote agriculture activities meanwhile maintain sustainable ecosystem in tribes.

Materials and methods

A. Investigation on species of key pests and natural enemies in paddy and orchard

Based on the specialty of local agricultural products, the investigation were done in rice paddies in Ceroh tribe, Yuli, Hualien (Fig.1A) and in pomelo orchards in Olalip tribe, Ruisu, Hualien (Fig.1B).

1. Rice paddies in Ceroh tribe

There were 3 organic and 3 conventional investigation paddies (Fig.1A), and each of them was at least 0.3 hectare. Each paddy was divided into several 100m2 (10m×10m) area, and we randomly chose 3 areas to do the sampling. The investigation underwent 5 growth stages of rice including transplanting, tillering, booting/heading, milky/doughy and yellow ripe stage. During the transplanting stage, we sampled the insects by yellow sticky traps on ridges. In other stages, despite the traps, we also walked into paddies and collected insects by sweeping net (Fig.2). Brought back the collected samples and sticky traps then examined by stereomicroscope (Leica, Germany). The targets of key pests were planthoppers (Delphacidae), leafhoppers, leaffolders (Cnaphalocrocis medinalis) and stem borers (Chilo suppressalis). The natural enemies were ladybugs (Micraspis discolor), spiders (Tetragnathidae), parasitoid wasps (Ichneumonid, Braconidae, Trichogrammatidae, Pteromalidae, Eulophidae and Mymaridae), Empididae and Ochthera sp.

2. Pomelo orchards in Olalip tribe

There were 3 organic and 3 conventional investigation orchards (Fig.1B), and each of them was at least 0.3 hectare. Each orchard was also divided into several 100m2 (10m×10m) area, and we randomly chose 3 areas to do the sampling. The investigation underwent 6 growth stages of pomelo including differentiation of flower bud, flowering, fruiting (small, medium and large) and fallow stage. In each sampling area, we collected the insects by beat netting one pomelo tree (Fig.3), and put yellow sticky traps on grass beneath. Brought back the collected samples and sticky traps then examined by stereomicroscope (Leica, Germany). The targets of key pests were thrips, aphids, flies and stinkbugs. The natural enemies were Anthocoridae, hover flies (Syrphidae), lacewings (Syrphidae), ladybugs (Coccinellidae), parasitoid wasps (Braconidae, Chalcididae, Eupelmidae, Scelionidae and Ichneumonid) and spiders.

B. Lifespan assay of natural enemies on aboriginal plants

To enrich ecological diversity and create a suitable environment for beneficial natural enemies are the suggested ways to regulate and control pests. At the same time, we can possibly reduce the usage and cost of chemical pesticides. By creating habitat with specific aboriginal plants on ridges and bared land in pomelo orchards, we hoped to increase the numbers and species of beneficial natural enemies. The plants were preliminary screened and chosen by cultivation traits, flowering season, adaptability to the weather, and abilities or duration time to provide nectar. These aboriginal plants were kept in and provided from Lanyang branch. And then we grew them in the greenhouse in Hualien for experiment. Finally 13 species were chosen and including herbal plants Anster indicus L., Mesona chinensis, Gonostegia hirta (Blume) Miq., Wedelia chinesis (Osbeck) Merr., Houttuynia cordata Thunb., Phyla nodiflora (L.) Greene. and Indigofera spicata Forsk., which were grown in 3 inches pots, and woody ones Vitex trifolia Linn., Vitex negundo L., Cajanus cajan (L.) Huth., Zanthoxylum ailanthoides, Hibiscus syriacus L., and Callicarpa formosana, which were grown in larger pots. All the experimental plants were kept to the flowering stage and the assay was done by that time.

1. Lifespan assay of parasitic natural enemy

Dirhinus giffardii (Hymenoptera: Chalcididae) (Fig.4) were reported having great effects on controlling fruit fly (Bactrocera dorsalis) in orchards in Taiwan. In our research, D. giffardii was the representative species of parasitic natural enemy. The eggs were kindly provided by Miaoli DARES. 3 days after the insects hatched, we put one mature female D. giffardii on the assay plant and observed its survival time. The experimental groups were plants with flowers or not, and the control group was only water provided. This year we did the assay on 10 plants except V. negundo, Z. ailanthoides and H. syriacus. In case of escaping of insects, the herbs pot were put in the PET cup (11.7cm in bottom diameter) and cover the lid with 30 cm 100-mesh net on it (Fig.5). The woody plants were covering by 71×48 cm (L×W) 100-mesh net.

2. Lifespan assay of predacious natural enemy

Ladybug Cheilomenes sexmaculata (Coleoptera) (Fig.6) were the representative species of predacious natural enemy. This ladybug was the product from Good Farms Co., Ltd. The experimental groups were plants with flowers or not, and the control group was only water provided.

Figure 1. Investigation fields. A. Rice paddies in Ceroh tribe. B. Pomelo orchards in Olalip tribe. Yellow sites are organic fields and red sites are conventional ones.
Figure 2. Sampling insects by sweeping net in rice paddy.
Figure 3. Sampling insects by beat netting in pomelo orchard.
Figure 4. Dirhinus giffardii is the representative parasitic insect. Source: https://www.mdais.gov.tw/files/mdais/web_structure/6044/A01_1.pdf
Figure 5. The lifespan assay of aboriginal plants in greenhouse.
Figure 6. Ladybug Cheilomenes sexmaculata is the representative predacious insect.

Results

A. Investigation on species of key pests and natural enemies in paddy and orchard

1. Rice paddies in Ceroh tribe

In our sampling investigation, the number of insects were higher in organic paddies than in conventional ones, especially spiders (Tetragnathidae), Empididae and leafhoppers (Fig.7). In conventional paddies, the population of planthoppers (pest) suddenly raised in booting stage and maintained this high level till the harvest. And total number of parasitoid wasps stayed flat (Fig.7A). However, in organic ones, late to the milky stage the population of planthoppers raised to the same level and showed the trend of decline in yellow ripe stage. At the same time total number of parasitoid wasps increased (Fig.7B).

The yellow sticky traps data from ridges showed similar trend in two kind of paddies. Total number of parasitoid wasps and Empididae were higher before heading stage in organic ridges than in conventional ones (Fig.8). The population of parasitoid wasps reached to the highest level, 266 in organic paddies and 187 in conventional ones, in transplanting stage. The population decreased in tillering stage while slightly increase again in booting/flowering stage.

2. Pomelo orchards in Olalip tribe

In our beat netting investigation, the number of insects were mostly under or around 50, and there were more natural enemies in organic orchards, especially spiders (Fig.9). The spider population were obviously more stable in organic orchards. During small fruits stage, the population of thrips (pest) intensely reached to 345 in conventional orchards (Fig.9A). However, in organic orchards, population of thrips and aphids were highest in flowering stage, average 46 and 54.7, which were still low compared with conventional ones (Fig.9B).

The yellow sticky traps data from grass beneath pomelo trees showed that parasitoid wasps were the dominant beneficial insects. The population reached the highest level in differentiation of flower bud stage (Fig.10). In small fruit stage, parasitoid wasps population reached to 551 in organic orchards and obviously higher than 262 in conventional ones. In addition, 326 out of 551 was identified to Braconidae (data not showed), which was the main natural enemies to fruit flies and moths. In medium fruit stage, population of ladybugs reached to 22.3 in organic orchards and obviously higher than 1.6 in conventional ones.

B. Lifespan assay of natural enemies on aboriginal plants

1. Lifespan assay of parasitic natural enemy

The results showed that 7 aboriginal plants including A. indicus, M. chinensis, W. chinesis, H. cordata, I. spicata, V. trifolia, C. cajan and C. formosana could extend the lifespan of D. giffardii (Fig.11). And it could survive the longest on I. spicata (31.1 days), V. trifolia (30.8 days) and A. indicus (30.2) (Fig.12).

2. Lifespan assay of predacious natural enemy

Lifespan of ladybug C. sexmaculata is average 0.5-3 months depend on environment and food. In our first trial, ladybugs were all died in two days. And then we put aphids together in the assay to see whether ladybugs could survive longer. However, ladybugs survived only 2 days more. Finally, we used the pupa in our assay and solved the survival problems. When ladybugs underwent eclosion on experimental plant we start to record its survival time. We took some time to solve the survival problems. And now this part of experiment is still ongoing.

Figure 7. The insect species and number in rice paddies by sweeping net. A. Conventional farming. B. Organic farming. Pests are in dotted lines and natural enemies are solid lines.
Figure 8. The insect species and number in ridges by yellow sticky traps. A. Conventional farming. B. Organic farming. Pests are in dotted lines and natural enemies are solid lines.
Figure 9. The insect species and number in pomelo orchards by beat netting. A. Conventional farming. B. Organic farming. Pests are in dotted lines and natural enemies are solid lines.
Figure 10. The insect species and number in pomelo orchards by yellow sticky traps. A. Conventional farming. B. Organic farming. Pests are in dotted lines and natural enemies are solid lines.
Figure 11. Life assay of Dirhinus giffardii on aboriginal plants.
Figure 12. Aboriginal plants that could extend the lifespan of Dirhinus giffardii. A. Indigofera spicata. B. Vitex trifolia. C. Anster indicus.

Conclusions and future works

Whether investigation in paddies or in pomelo orchards, the results showed that the population of natural enemies were higher and more stable in organic fields. The reasons might be there were no chemical pesticides and herbicides usage in organic fields. Meanwhile there were grass or plants on the ridges and orchards, and that provided food and habitats for beneficial insects. In pomelo orchards, the population of key pest- thrips in small fruit stage were highly different between two farming fields. We also recorded that the spiders could exist stably in organic orchids. Spiders are main predators to many pests. Based on our data, spiders may play the important role in pest regulation in pomelo orchards. We also recorded that Barconidae were the main parasitoid wasps (data not showed) in organic orchards. They are the main parasitic natural enemies of fruit flies. If there is Barconidae population stably survive in orchards, they may help to regulate key pests. This kind of parasitoid wasps may also be the indicator species in our further research.

The purpose of the lifespan assay is to screen out the suitable aboriginal plants for habitat creation. Based on preliminary results, we can see that D. giffardii can survive on I. spicata, V. trifolia and A. indicus the longest time. These plants are common aboriginal plants and they all possess good cultivation traits. If these plants grow and stably exist in fields, they can provide alternate shelter for parasitoid wasps. So, now we continuously cultivate these plants in our experimental fields and greenhouse. And we are going to plant these plants in rice ridges and pomelo orchards in our future assay. Investigation and comparison will be carefully done between the assay with these plants or not. In the future, we hope to provide the solution for promoting agriculture activities meanwhile maintain sustainable ecosystem in tribes, especially in organic ways.

References

  1. Crossman, N. D., Bryan, A. B., Groot, R. S., Lin, Y. P. and Minang, P. A. 2013. Land science contributions to ecosystem services. Current Opinion in Environmental Sustainability. 5: 509-514.
  2. Daines, M. et al. 2019. A global synthesis reveals biodiversity-mediated benefits for crop production. Science advances. 5-10:0121.
  3. Fan, M. L., Tsai, S. S., Lin, T. Y., Ni, Y. T., Hwang, P. and Lee, K. C. 2013. The effects of agricultural practices on invertebrate diversity in the rice paddy land of eastern Taiwan. Bulletin of the Hualien District Agricultural Research and Extension Station 31: 53-64. (in Chinese).
  4. Fan, M. L., Yu, C. Y. and Lin, L. 2016. Indicator species for agrobiodiversity in rice paddy fields: research and its application to a new eco labelling scheme in eastern rural Taiwan. International Partnership for the Satoyama Initiative. Malaysia. https://satoyama-initiative.org/casestudies (case studies).
  5. Kacaw, D. 2021. Edible wild greens of Taiwan’s Pangcah people. My House Publishing Co., Ltd. Taipei, Taiwan.
  6. Lin, L., HO, Y. T. and Fan, M. L. 2016. “Ecological agriculture” that combines farmers’ livelihood, production, and ecology with a win-win situation. Agriculture Policy and Review. 292: 52-57. (in Chinese).
  7. Lin, L. and Yang, T. C. 2012. Study of hedge plants on pest control. Bulletin of the Hualien District Agricultural Research and Extension Station 30: 33-40. (in Chinese).
  8. Rensburg, W. J., Averbeke, W., Slabbert, R., Faber, M., Jaarsveld, P., Heerden, I., Wenhold, F. and Oelofse, A. 2007. African leafy vegetables in South Africa. African Journals Online. 3: 317-326.
  9. Kopta, T., Pokluda, R. and Psota, V. 2012. Attractiveness of flowering plants for natural enemies. Hort. Sci. 39:89-96.
  10. Kozar, R., Galang, E., Sedhain, J., Alip, A., Subramanian, S. M., and Saito, O. 2020. Place-based solutions for conservation and restoration of social-ecological production landscapes and seascapes in Asia. Managing socio-ecological production landscapes and seascapes for sustainable communities in Asia. Springer. Singapore. 117-146.
  11. Phillips-Howard, K.D. 1999. The indigenization of exotic inputs by small-scale farmers on the Jos Plateau, Nigeria. Biological and cultural diversity: the role of indigenous agricultural experimentation in development. Intermediate. Technology Publications. London, UK. 80-91.
  12. Wyckhuys, K. A. G., Lu, Y., Morales, H., Vazquez, L. L., Legaspi, J. C., Eliopoulos, P. A. and Hernandez, L. M. 2013. Current status and potential of conservation biological control for agriculture in the developing world .Biological Control. 65:152-167.
  13. Yen, G. E., Pan, K. C. Hsu, C. Y. and Lee, K. C. 2020. The utility of vegetated buffer strip for mediating fertilizer content in surface runoff from paddy rice fields. International Conference on Eco-Agriculture: Technology Development and Landscape Management. 39-45. (in Chinese).

Website links: Hualien District Agricultural Research and Extension Station (HDARES) https://www.hdares.gov.tw/en/